Thursday 11 January 2018

Food Festival in Benazir Bhutto Park – An Overt Violation of Law


On May 19, 2017, the Infocus published a post on these pages pointing out at the holding of a commercial festival in Khulfa e Rashdeen Park at 13-D, Gulshan e Iqbal and stated that it was a violation of law by DMC East. While strong apprehensions were also raised in the post that “if this (violation) would (not) become a future trend”. That festival badly ruined the park infrastructure, greenery and serenity at the end of the day so badly that DMC East hasn’t yet recovered that all till this date.

However, above apprehensions seems to be turning into realities. Again, civic rules are being violated and an event of festivity “Karachi Eat Food Festival” is being arranged from January 12 to 14, 2017 in the city’ one of the most prestigious public place the Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park, located in Clifton, DMC South. Previous two editions of the event had also been arranged at Frere Hall alongside Bagh e Jinnah, which attracted massive crowd for fun and food activities, leading the festival to become an annual event. There is no doubt the festival is a popular and successful addition on the metropolitan recreational landscape but holding it in a public park have consequences too.

That’s the reason which has led many concerned bodies including the National Forum for Environment and Health (NFEH) to ask the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation (KMC) not to allow a central public park to host any food festival. The Forum rightly opined in a press conference that holding such commercial event in pubic park violates the very basic purpose for which the urban open spaces are meant for. “The public parks are like essential public open spaces in a city like Karachi and in no way these spaces should be used to host a commercial activity, which has every potential to damage the very basic components and essentials of a park” it argues.

Parks are important for people, especially the urban communities, to stay fit and sane. Apart from offering recreational pleasure to the city’ dwellers, parks are places where people are kept in touch with nature. That’s the basic and foremost purpose of any park which is prioritized and upheld world over. Any act that disrupts this basic purpose should be discouraged therefore.     

Furthermore the Supreme Court of Pakistan already gave a ruling in 2010 against holding commercial activities in public parks and declared it violation of Article 26 of Constitution of Pakistan. The ruling stated that parks are purpose of providing facilities, charm and temptation to general public in good faith and must not be used for any commercial activity.

It is also important to mention that millions of rupees are spent each year for the maintenance of Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park -- built on 47 acres of land -- but after holding such commercial activities the very essence of park in terms of aesthetic and horticultural aspects will be severely deteriorated and all public spending for maintenance will go in vain. And, in current scenario this probable deterioration would be irreparable because city’ municipal authorities don’t have sufficient funds to repair and renovate the beauty and infrastructure of the park again.

Therefore, the NFEH has solid reason that the food festival has every potential to damage the very basic components and essentials of Park. However, it is also noteworthy that Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park is no longer in the custody of KMC right now as in May 2017 on the directives of Sindh Local Government, the Karachi Development Authority took over the charge of the park.


Hope sanity prevails in governmental corridors.


By 

Editorial, Infocus

No comments:

Post a Comment